Social Talk


Sorry there are no tags yet

Cinnamon Carter

Manipulation of the Truth: Where is it leading us?

Manipulation of the Truth Where is it leading us

I recently became aware of a new term coined by Stanford University professor Robert N. Proctor.  The term is agnotology described by Professor Proctor as “culturally constructed ignorance, created by special interest groups to create confusion and suppress truth in a societally important issue.”  He uses it in the context of being especially useful to create seeds of doubt in complex scientific issues by publishing inaccurate or misleading data.  The best known example according to Proctor is the tobacco industry’s claims that evidence of smoking cigarettes causes cancer was “not yet in.”  This was an outright lie when scientific evidence had proved that smoking caused cancer, emphysema, heart and lung disease.  According to Proctor “The tobacco industry is famous for having seen itself as a manufacturer of two different products: tobacco and doubt.”  That doubt allowed cigarette sales to continue for decades before the truth surfaced and allowed state and federal oversight.

Current agnotology campaigns affect a variety of public-policy issues where enough doubt has been generated through false statements, inflammatory rhetoric and data from suspicious sources that mislead public opinion, if only for a time.  Examples of current rhetoric include:

  • Iraq has weapons of mass destruction
  • Genetically modified crops are dangerous
  • Global warming is a scientific hoax
  • Vaccines cause autism
  • Tax cuts pay for themselves
  • Poor people caused the financial crisis

All of these statements are inaccurate and lack any factual basis.  However, there are people who believe these misstatements and falsehoods.  It would appear that the current presidential campaigns are totally based on the definition of agnotology.  Each side generating falsehoods, using inflammatory rhetoric, and quoting data from dubious sources to mislead the public.  According to Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes “democracy” is meant to be “a market place of ideas” and debates are meant to present arguments to reach a truth.  By the time voters go to the polls their knowledge of the details will be well-known, the finer points discussed, and they will understand what they are voting for and the consequences.  However, our present presumptive candidates seem to be using agotology to win short-term victories at any and all costs.  A quote by Jonathan Swift says it all “Falsehood flies, and the Truth comes limping after it.”  The thought of the consequences of voters not knowing what they are really voting for is frightening.

We expect hyperbole and exaggeration in political campaigns.  However, alternate realities is another thing.  We all seem to be living in different dimensions if not on different planets.

What do you think?

Cinnamon Carter

Similar Stories
Social Talk

Submitting DNA

Just like Cambridge Analytica rocked Facebook, submitting your DNA to one of those genealogy sites is a threat to your privacy.

Social Talk

Recycling: Myth or helping the planet?

Recycling: Myth or helping the planet?  Truth or Dare (not to protect the earth)?
#1: Recycling uses more energy than making something...

Social Talk

5 Habits of the Fountain of Youth

5 Habits to the Fountain of Youth?  Well, not exactly.
The five healthy lifestyle factors identified in a new study published in the...

Social Talk

Why Baby Boomers are hitting the Bottle – and I don’t mean feeding their grandchildren

Those of us at a certain age, traditionally assume that teenagers and college-age people are the demographic groups that drink the...

Social Talk

How New Technology Tricks You into Forgetting Things – Losing my mind or losing my cellphone?

There was a time, long, long ago, in an era that is now far, far away, it was impossible to lose your phone.  Why, you say?  Because the...

Social Talk

Beware: Nothing in life is free

Those of us not born into the age of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram – you get the idea, have long known nothing in life is free and if...

Social Talk

The World is Still Populated and Run by Humans

So shouldn’t people in every city considering autonomous cars be asked if they want to allow them and if so, in what function?

Social Talk

Technology: To help and protect us or a brain drain?

We design technology to assist us, provide warnings for us, prevent us from getting hurt, to provide checks and balances, and even take...

Social Talk

Have you developed internet anxiety?

You are probably thinking this is about being anxious about using the internet.  Guess what, it is not (or is it?).  This is about the...

Social Talk

Is constant & continual progress necessary? When is it time to stop?

It seems that there is no final frontier.  Human kind has investigated and continues to investigate the earth, the planets, the oceans,...