Social Talk



Cinnamon Carter

Is Immigration the Real Issue?

Is Immigration the Real Issue or Our Ineptness as a Country?
unfair immigration

There are an estimated 53,000 unauthorized immigrants in the New Jersey who could apply for protected status under Obama’s executive order allowing those brought to the United States as children to remain in the US and work legally under the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals Program (DACA).  A status that must be renewed every two years.  Only 23,000 or 43 percent have done so.  New Jersey is the 15th (tied with Connecticut and Maryland) out of 20 states with the most unauthorized immigrants that are eligible for the program.  According to Sara Culliname, state director of Make the Road New Jersey, a group that helps unauthorized immigrants: “There is a real dearth of affordable immigration legal services in New Jersey.”  This has made it difficult for eligible individuals to apply.  Nationally, 1.3 million immigrants were eligible and 63 percent applied.  A second executive order allowing the parents of children who are American citizens or legal residents and have lived in the US for at least five years to work legally and not be deported known as Deferred Action for Parents of Americans and Lawful Permanent Residents (DAPA) was rejected by the Supreme Court.  New Jersey was one of the states asking for overturn of the action.  But there is another side to this issue that reflects not just access to legal services, but the conundrum once an individual finds themselves inside the legal process because legal immigrants face deportation as well.  And all immigrants are not from Mexico or Asia.


Deportation statistics include legal residents and people with valid visas, not just illegal or “undocumented” immigrants.  Who are these people?  Legal immigrants who have become American Citizens and are deported due to misdemeanors that occurred decades ago due to lack of understanding about the legal system and its consequences.  In the mid 1990’s, Congress passed two bills that significantly expanded the list of “crimes” leading to deportation.  But there is a catch here.  Many lawyers were unaware of the new rules until 9/11 when the Department of Homeland Security started enforcing them.  The laws were applied retroactively for “crimes” that occurred decades earlier.  Judges became unable to decide cases based on individual circumstances.  Is this what American democracy is about?  What happened to due process and justice?  Adding insult to injury, the treatment of people once in the detention system is disturbing.  For example:

  • Little to no contact is allowed with the outside world
  • There is little access to a phone, but when available it costs one dollar per minute, collect
  • Legal documents never get delivered to the addressee
  • To send mail, stamps and envelopes need to be purchased but access is not granted to money in the commissary until you are detained for several weeks
  • You can be awakened in the middle of the night and shackled, to be moved to another prison but while in line, can be pulled out for no obvious reason to be locked up in solitary confinement for several days.
  • Immigration officers will say the best way to end the nightmare is to sign papers agreeing to leave the US forever (some immigrants having lived here legally for twenty years)
  • Many are deported without ever speaking to an attorney
  • Non-citizens have no right to an attorney but if they are able to hire one are more likely to win their case
  • Legal permanent residents serve mandatory and indefinite detention while waiting for a final decision or an appeal (which can take years)
  • No one is granted a bond hearing even though there is no proof they are a flight risk (for the “benefit” of for-profit prison companies)
  • Data released by the government suggests large amounts of money is spent on non-priority cases with failure on the part of immigration to focus on serious criminals
  • Only half of the immigrants last year had any convictions
  • The secretive process by Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) grants few rights to those caught in the system
  • Deportation is done for minor mistakes; most don’t get a fair hearing before a judge


Forcing people to live in exile is harsh and separates children from parents, spouses from each other, and adults from their parents.  I thought the goal of our court system was to keep families together and not categorically perceive all immigrants as dangerous.  Is this now the American Way?


What do you think?


(Derived from articles in the Star-Ledger: Jonathan D. Salant, 8/14/16, Susan Stellin, 8/26/16)

Cinnamon Carter

Similar Stories
Social Talk

Submitting DNA

Just like Cambridge Analytica rocked Facebook, submitting your DNA to one of those genealogy sites is a threat to your privacy.

Social Talk

Recycling: Myth or helping the planet?

Recycling: Myth or helping the planet?  Truth or Dare (not to protect the earth)?
#1: Recycling uses more energy than making something...

Social Talk

5 Habits of the Fountain of Youth

5 Habits to the Fountain of Youth?  Well, not exactly.
The five healthy lifestyle factors identified in a new study published in the...

Social Talk

Why Baby Boomers are hitting the Bottle – and I don’t mean feeding their grandchildren

Those of us at a certain age, traditionally assume that teenagers and college-age people are the demographic groups that drink the...

Social Talk

How New Technology Tricks You into Forgetting Things – Losing my mind or losing my cellphone?

There was a time, long, long ago, in an era that is now far, far away, it was impossible to lose your phone.  Why, you say?  Because the...

Social Talk

Beware: Nothing in life is free

Those of us not born into the age of Facebook, Twitter, Instagram – you get the idea, have long known nothing in life is free and if...

Social Talk

The World is Still Populated and Run by Humans

So shouldn’t people in every city considering autonomous cars be asked if they want to allow them and if so, in what function?

Social Talk

Technology: To help and protect us or a brain drain?

We design technology to assist us, provide warnings for us, prevent us from getting hurt, to provide checks and balances, and even take...

Social Talk

Have you developed internet anxiety?

You are probably thinking this is about being anxious about using the internet.  Guess what, it is not (or is it?).  This is about the...

Social Talk

Is constant & continual progress necessary? When is it time to stop?

It seems that there is no final frontier.  Human kind has investigated and continues to investigate the earth, the planets, the oceans,...